1954-55 (33 goals)

Liverpool actually had two players bag more than 30 goals in 1954-55 – and still didn’t gain promotion!

Evans scored his in batches, hitting all five in a 5-3 home victory over Bristol Rovers and each of the team’s four when Bury were beaten 4-3 on the road later that season.

Netting more than the prolific Liddell was no mean feat, but the club could only finish 11th.