6th: Danny Murphy (8, not out)
Also on eight is Danny Murphy, but the former Liverpool midfielder outdoes Dirk Kuyt and Phil Neal by virtue of being 'not out' with his remarkable run.
Time and again, the Englishman was coolness personified from 12 yards and finished his Reds career with a flawless penalty record – eight taken, eight scored.
His first came against Southampton in August 2002 and his last during a meeting with Middlesbrough in May 2004.
Murphy’s sweetest was no doubt the one converted past Manchester United a week previously, though, given it marked his third match-winning goal at Old Trafford.